Benni McCarthy Won't Be Back At AmaZulu FC, Says Agent Rob Moore

Holifil

05 Apr, 2025

Agent Rob Moore confirms Benni McCarthy is not returning to AmaZulu FC and suggests Steven Pienaar as a potential replacement.
Moore stated that McCarthy is not the right fit for the club, while fans on social media agree, predicting tough times for the PSL club.

Listen, folks, here's the scoop: According to football agent Rob Moore, the legendary Bafana Bafana striker, Benni McCarthy, is not even in the running for the vacant manager position at AmaZulu FC. If you're a fan of the club, this might come as a bit of a surprise, but let's dive into the details.

Now, here's where things get interesting. While Moore shot down McCarthy's chances, he didn’t leave the club hanging. Instead, he floated the name of another South African football icon—Steven Pienaar, the former Tottenham Hotspur and Everton star—as a viable option. That's a bold move, and it’s got people talking.

Bafana Bafana legend Benni McCarthy is among the names being discussed for the vacant managerial role at AmaZulu FC. Image: Matt McNulty. Source: Getty Images

For context, McCarthy was at the helm of Usuthu from 2020 to 2022, and many thought he might return after the club parted ways with Spanish coach Pablo Franco Martin. But as it turns out, that’s not happening anytime soon.

Read also:
How To Open A Pep Account Online In South Africa A Stepbystep Guide

Why Benni McCarthy Isn’t an Option for AmaZulu FC

Let me break it down for you. In a recent tweet, Moore was crystal clear about McCarthy's situation with AmaZulu. He didn’t mince words, saying it’s time for the club to look beyond Benni and explore other avenues.

As Goal.com reported, Moore expressed that AmaZulu should steer clear of hiring McCarthy, urging them to consider other candidates who might be a better fit for the job. Here's what Moore had to say:

"There’s absolutely no possibility of Benni returning to AmaZulu. I’ve already given them my recommendation on who they should pursue. I’ve suggested they try to bring in Steven Pienaar; trust me, he’d do a fantastic job for them."

Social Media Fans Are on Board with Moore

You know what they say—social media never sleeps. Fans on platforms like Twitter were quick to weigh in, echoing Moore's sentiments. Many predicted tough times ahead for AmaZulu if they were to bring McCarthy back, suggesting that he should focus his efforts elsewhere.

Simlindile Ayabonga Ngcongela chimed in with a telling observation:

"Something strange is brewing. Haibo, four coaches already? This is getting wild."

Lebokgang Lancelot seemed to back Moore’s suggestion wholeheartedly:

"Absolutely. It would be great to see Schillo take the reins. Let’s do this!"

Not everyone was on board, though. Lesson ST Bronze wasn’t a fan of Moore’s approach:

Read also:
Trinity Morisette The Young Influencer Making Waves On Social Media

"This agent is clearly pushing their own agenda, trying to find a job for Pienaar. But let’s be real, we haven’t seen Pienaar coaching in the Motsepe League yet."

Wisani Mathebula added a bit of perspective:

"AmaZulu is slowly turning into Chippa United. This is concerning."

And Ezra Matjila had this to say about McCarthy:

"Benni deserves better. He should tell them he’s big team material and move on."

Benni McCarthy Opens Up About Erik ten Hag

Switching gears a bit, let’s talk about McCarthy’s recent comments on another football heavyweight—Erik ten Hag. As reported by Briefly News, the Bafana Bafana legend opened up about his former Manchester United boss. McCarthy served under Ten Hag for two seasons as the forward’s coach, and his take on the Dutchman might surprise you.

McCarthy expressed concerns about Ten Hag's approach, particularly after the club’s underwhelming start to the 2024/2025 Premiership season. He believes that the manager lacks the passion needed to drive the team forward, and that’s a bold statement coming from someone who knows the game inside and out.